LEASING VS DRIVER REIMBURSEMENT
LEASING
DRIVER REIMBURSEMENT
Leasing is an efficient and economical method of vehicle acquisition and fleet administration. It allows a company to preserve capital for expansion or research, to improve cash flow or for business improvements. It also provides a strong management and assessment tool for their fleet performance.
Driver reimbursement generally represents great disadvantages to a company’s employee. The perk of being able to select any vehicle the driver wishes is soon outweighed by the increased costs, record keeping and the impact to his/her personal financial situation. It also offers the least amount of control by the employer over operating costs, safety and reflection on the company.
   
ADVANTAGES
ADVANTAGES
Control over image and suitability of vehicle Unlimited vehicle selection to driver
Vehicle under manufacturer warranty majority of road life Purchasing, maintenance and selling are done by the employee
Maximizes company fleet costs Monthly costs are fixed
Paying only for actual vehicle value usage The employee does mileage tracking and reporting
Purchasing power due to lessor’s volume and association in auto industry No balance sheet effect to the company
Competitive funding rates warranted by company’s financial strength No company tracking management necessary
No upfront costs No vehicle costs exposure due to terminated/transferred employee
Sales tax on payment only where use/rental tax applies    
Predetermined pricing with discounts not always available to employee
DISADVANTAGES
Unrestricted choice of make & model No control over vehicle selection, condition and resulting reflection on company image
Professional expertise in vehicle selection Longer use resulting in higher repair costs/operating costs
Lease experts managing and monitoring fleet effectiveness and efficiency No assurance of safety/reliability of vehicle
Vehicle maintenance monitored to maximize vehicle performance More downtime when company not monitoring maintenance
Budgetable, predictable monthly cash flow Vehicle generally more expensive/lack of purchasing power
Consolidated monthly billing Initial cash outlay required by employee personally
Lease-end vehicle values maximized due to options available for used vehicle disposal/remarketing   Funding more expensive
Off blance sheet transactions Personal insurance more expensive due to business use
    Alternate transportation utilized to save vehicle value
DISADVANTAGES
Company liability exposure for vehicle used as business tool
Exposed to fluctuations in used vehicle market 100% sales tax exposure to employee
Limited under certain tax situations Retail only incentives available to employee
Liability exposure Employee responsible for legal registration/operation
    Tax reform has reduced tax benefits to ownership
    Limited remarketing options
    Negative equity exposure to employee due to vehicle usage value outpacing monthly payment
    Employee dissatisfaction
    Loss of recruitment and/or employee retention
       
Copyright © 2002 [Bergstrom Corporation]. All rights reserved
Powerd and Designed by John Ernst Corporation Powerd and Designed by John Ernst Corporation Powerd and Designed by John Ernst Corporation
Powerd and Designed by John Ernst Corporation